Cobblestone is back - but should it be?

Last night Valve pushed a big new update with the Major hub and stickers (including some interesting changes to the pricing after the complaints last time out), but most importantly, Cobblestone.
Cobblestone has stepped away from it's gloomy, iconic cobbled streets (hence the name) to a snowy castle that sits somewhere between a place James Bond would go 45 minutes into the film for some non-sequitur-but-really-cool set-piece, and Disney villian's lair. That is to say; it does look pretty wicked, if not faithful to the original.
It's good to see some diversity in the map pool in the sense that it's a white map instead of a sandy one, though we will miss the OG Cobble, regardless of its flaws. This map is changed somewhat too, and while it's too early to know how impactful those changes are and what they impact (our guess is not too much), it's clear Valve are dedicated to trying to make Cobble work this time.
But should Valve be trying to make Cobble work?
We think so, yeah.
It's become something of a status marker to signal how little you miss Cobble, and that it really wasn't that good, that nostalgia is blinding people and all of those catchphrases people repeat. The sentiment that 'you don't miss Cobble, you miss 2017' is one that has been commonplace in the last few years, and while that's not totally unfair - the writer of this piece certainly misses being 21 and being able to play CS all day - it's not the only motivating factor.
Cobblestone is simply just a fun map to play.
It doesn't have to be more complicated than that. The fact that as a community there are so many memories of this map - memories that don't really exist for other maps that have been in and out of the pool (looking at you, Vertigo) - suggests that people really did enjoy playing and watching the map. We can remember some huge moments from pro play, crazy games, times we actually enjoyed ourselves playing it. It's not just nostalgia. It really happened!
And anyway, even if it was just nostalgia - do you have any other reason for having Dust 2 in the map pool?
Nostalgia is a perfectly good reason for trying to make Cobble work. It might not - the flaws might be too much. It might be too difficult to figure out how to stop the Ts rushing B 11 rounds a half. It might be that drop is still just a nightmare for both teams. It could be the A side of the map is still horrendous - though this writer quite liked OG Cobble's A site as one of the most unique sites in the game, unique =/= good.
Good luck going up ramp.
That doesn't mean we should give up. There's clearly something there that resonates with people. So many people are happy to see it back even though it isn't perfect, and that tells you that it has character, it has memories attached to it, people enjoy it despite. If you can iron out the flaws - or even just water them down a bit - you will have a genuine all-timer map that won't ever have to leave the pool.
People already love it before it's good. Anubis didn't even have that grace and still made it.
A friend of mine always used to make the point about Vertigo that nobody could really name a memorable game of Vertigo, and though I'd never tell him, I always thought it was a fair point. Vertigo was not quite as unbalanced and horrible as people used to claim, but it rarely gave us big moments, great maps, memories. Cobblestone, for all its issues, some not dissimilar to the issues of Vertigo, was a part of some phenomenal games, crazy clips, moments in history.
They've brought back Cache, a map that has problems that haven't been solved and could also harbour claims of nostalgia-bait, and guess what? It's still fun. It's still fun to play the maps I played when I fell in love with the game. Maybe that makes me a sheep, blindly nostalgic, a halfwit, whatever.
It's fun to relive one of the best maps in Counter-Strike history.
Bring back Cobblestone. Make it better. Or don't. I'll still be there, full blind, cowering behind statue as the Ts rush me down.
With a big beaming smile on my face.